Trailing at halftime at Exploria Stadium, FC Cincinnati flipped the script in the second half, with Evander at the center of everything. The Brazilian forward equalized from the penalty spot just before the break, then put Cincinnati ahead four minutes into the second half, and later fed Gidi for the clincher in the 85th minute. Pat Noonan’s side advance to the Round of 16, ending Orlando City’s season at home.

Key Moments
- 26′, Ojeda opens the scoring for Orlando City, converting after Angulo plays him in.
- 43′, Evander levels from the penalty spot to send the teams into the break level at 1-1.
- 45′, Cincinnati make two changes at halftime, sending on Powell for Robinson and Martínez for Hagglund.
- 49′, Evander puts Cincinnati in front for the first time, finishing from a Barlow pass four minutes into the second half.
- 85′, Gidi seals it, converting an Evander assist to make it 3-1 and put the result beyond doubt.
Tactical Breakdown
Orlando City dominated possession, finishing with 58% and 27 total shots compared to Cincinnati’s 10, yet those numbers could not translate into goals after the opening half-hour. Cincinnati’s 3-5-2 stayed compact and aggressive off the ball, holding their shape through a sustained first-half barrage that saw Orlando post an xG of 2.99 for the match. Celentano made six saves to keep the gap manageable.
The two halftime substitutions by Pat Noonan changed the texture of the game. Robinson and Hagglund, both carrying 45 minutes, were replaced, and the reshuffled back line gave Cincinnati more energy in transition. Within four minutes of the restart, Evander was running at a disorganized Orlando defense and finishing calmly for 2-1. Orlando responded with three substitutions by the 55th minute, but interim coach Martín Perelman could not find a way to reorganize around the goal deficit.
Orlando’s undoing was defensive. After Ojeda’s opener and the half-time scoreline of 1-1, the Lions had enough possession to control the second half but lacked the structure to do so. With 21 shots inside the box and an xG of 2.99, the numbers suggest they created chances, yet they finished with just one goal. Cincinnati’s willingness to play direct when they had the ball limited Orlando’s ability to press high, and once Evander had the lead, the home side had to open up, which only created more space for the visitors on the break.
Player Ratings
Major League Soccer knockout bracket
Affiliate disclosure: the links below are affiliate links. If you buy through them, Soccer Legends may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Knockout results, aggregate scores across legs; winners in bold, penalty shootouts noted.
Head to Head
Verdict
FC Cincinnati move on to the Round of 16, where they will face a higher-seeded Eastern Conference side after finishing ninth in the conference. For Orlando City, it is an early exit at home, their season ending on 46 points after a second half they were unable to shape despite controlling possession. Evander’s three-goal involvement was the story of the night and signals that Cincinnati, however they arrived here, are a threat going deeper into the postseason.


FC Cincinnati
Orlando City SC
Evander